The first question, is anyone from outside qualified to arbitrate what is going inside campus? refers to the debate over whether individuals who are not affiliated with a particular campus community have the authority to make judgments about what happens within that community. In general, it can be argued that outsiders may not have a complete understanding of the complex social, political, and academic dynamics that shape campus life. They may lack the necessary context to accurately interpret events or make informed decisions about how to respond to them. Moreover, outsiders may not be aware of the unique challenges and opportunities that students, faculty, and staff face in their particular campus environment. That being said, there are certainly instances where outside perspectives can be valuable. For example, outside experts may be able to provide insights into issues related to safety, equity, or academic integrity that are not immediately apparent to those who are immersed in t...